A Tale of Two Thresholds


Our study follows the work produced by pre-service teachers in six of our required history seminars to analyse how their ideas about "what good historians do" and "what good history teachers do" changed over the semester. These pre-service teachers need to pass through two portals in their thinking: one, to develop a less novice-like understanding of how history functions as a discipline and, two, to move away from seeing their role as purveyors of single-stranded narratives that students should memorize, so that as teachers they can engage in teaching historical thinking. Through both a qualitative and quantitative analysis of the 62 pre and post surveys, and their final papers (a lesson plan), we found that students’ performance in their lesson plans was more closely correlated with their ability to articulate what historians do than it was with their ability to articulate what history teachers do. Indeed, statistical correlation was high. These finding suggests that teaching history and knowing the ways of thinking of this discipline are inseparable in the shaping of an effective history teacher, and that pre-service teachers must pass through the disciplinary portal before they can teach historical thinking to anyone else.


Bain, B. (2006). Rounding up unusual suspects: Confronting the hidden sources of authority in the classroom. Teachers College Record, 108(10), 2080-2114.

Barton, K. C., & Levstik, L. S. (2004). Teaching history for the common good. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

Barton, K. C. (2008) Narrative Simplifications in Elementary Students’ Historical Thinking. In L. Levstik & K. C. Barton, Researching History Education: Theory, Method, and Context, pp. 183-208. New York: Routledge.

Blizard, M., Dazey, T., Germano, N., Gwishiri, N., Mays, D., & Wheeler, V. (2013). Inside the Black Box: IU Students' Ideas about History. Paper presented at the Teaching and Practice Colloquium, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN: March 22.

Calder, L. (2006). Uncoverage: Toward a Signature Pedagogy for the History Survey. Journal of American History, 92(4), 1358-1370.

Chi, M. T. H., Feltovich, P. J., & Glaser, R. (1981). Categorization and Representation Physics Problems by Experts and Novices. Cognitive Science, 5, 121-152.

Davies, M. L. (2006). Historics: Why History Dominates Contemporary Society. London: Routledge.

Díaz, A., Middendorf, J., Pace, D., & Shopkow, L. (2008). The History Learning Project: A department ‘decodes’ its students. Journal of American History 94(4), 1211-1224.

Entwistle, N. (2008). Threshold Concepts and Transformative Ways of Thinking within Research into Higher Education. In R. Land, J. H. F. Meyer & J. Smith (Eds.), Threshold Concepts within the Disciplines, pp. 21-35. Rotterdam: Sense Publishers.

Indiana Department of Education. (2014). Indiana Academic Standards and Resource Guide. United States History 1877 to the Present. <http://www.doe.in.gov/sites/default/files/standards/socialstudies/ss-2014-ushistory-resources-20140718.pdf>, accessed October 9, 2014.

Lévesque, S. (2008) Thinking Historically: Educating Students for the Twenty-First Century. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

Martin, D., & Monte-Sano, C. (2008). Inquiry, controversy and ambiguous texts: Learning to teach for historical thinking. In W. J. Warren & D. Antonio Cantu (Eds.), History education 101: The past, present, and future of teacher education, pp. 167-86. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.

Meyer, J.H.F., & Land, R. (2006). Threshold concepts and troublesome knowledge: issues of liminality. In J.H.F. Meyer & R. Land (Eds.), Overcoming barriers to student understanding: Threshold concepts and troublesome knowledge, pp. 19-32. London: Routledge.

Orill, R., & Shapiro, L. (2005). From bold beginnings to an uncertain future: The discipline of history and history education. American Historical Review, 110(3), 727-751.

Pace, D., & Middendorf, J. (Eds.) (2004) Decoding the Disciplines: Helping Students Learn Disciplinary Ways of Thinking: New Directions for Teaching and Learning, 98. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Perkins, D. (2008). Making Learning Whole: How Seven Principles of Teaching Can Transform Education. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Shulman, L. S. (1986). Those Who Understand: Knowledge Growth in Teaching. Educational Researcher, 15(2), 4-14.

Szijártó, I. (2002). Four Arguments for Microhistory. Rethinking History: The Journal of Theory and Practice, 6(2), 209-15.

Seixas, P. (2000). Schweigen! die Kinder! or Does Postmodern History have a Place in the Schools? In P. Stearns, P. Seixas & S. Wineburg (Eds.), Knowing, Teaching, and Learning History: National and International Perspectives, pp.19-37. New York: New York University Press.

Shopkow, L., Díaz, A., Middendorf, J., & Pace, D. (2012). The History Learning Project “decodes†a discipline: The union of teaching and epistemology. In K. McKinney (Ed.), The scholarship of teaching and learning in and across the disciplines, pp. 93-113. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.

Shopkow, L., Díaz, A., Middendorf, J., & Pace, D. (2013). From Bottlenecks to Epistemology: Changing the Conversation about History in Colleges and Universities. In R.J. Thompson (Ed.),Changing the Conversation about Higher Education, pp. 15-37. Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield.

Sipress, J. M., & Voelker, D, J. (2009). From Learning History to Doing History: Beyond the Coverage Model. In A. R. Regan, N. L. Gurung, A. H. Chick, & A. A. Ciccone (Eds.), Exploring Signature Pedagogies: Approaches to Teaching Habits of Mind, pp. 19-35. Sterling, VA: Stylus.

Sipress, J. M., & Voelker, D. J. (2011).The End of the History Survey Course: The Rise and Fall of the Coverage Model. Journal of American History, 97(4), 1050-1066.

Thornton, S. J. (2001). Legitimacy in the Social Studies Curriculum. In L. Corno (Ed.), Education Across a Century: The Centennial Volume, National Society for the Study of Education Yearbook, Part 1, pp. 185-205. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

VanSledright, Bruce (2010). The Challenge of Rethinking History Education: On Practices, Theory, and Policy. New York: Routledge.

VanSledright, B., & Reddy, K. (2014). Changing Epistemic Beliefs? An Exploratory Study of Cognition among Prospective History Teachers. Revista Tempo e Argumento, 6(11), 28-68.

Wieman, C. (2006). A Scientific Approach to Science Education. Paper presented at Indiana University, Bloomington, October 27. Retrieved from: http://citl.indiana.edu/programs/sotl/events/2006_07/wieman2.php for abstract.

Wineburg, S. (1999) Historical Thinking and Other Unnatural Acts: Charting the Future of Teaching the Past. Philadelphia: Temple.

Wineburg, S., Martin, D., & Monte-Sano, C.(2012). Reading Like an Historian: Teaching Literacy in Middle and High School History Classrooms. 2nd ed. New York: Teachers College Press.

Authors retain the copyright for their work, while granting the journal the exclusive right of first publication. By virtue of their appearance in this open access journal, articles are free to use, with proper attribution, in educational and other non-commercial settings.